comments 8

Review: My Brilliant Career (Also The Franchise Affair, and You’ve Been Publicly Shamed)

I wasn’t intending to review Josephine Tey’s 1949 mystery, The Franchise Affair, but that was before I discovered that it was a jaw droppingly right wing treatise on social issues, rather than the gentle cosy detective story I’d been expecting.

Tey’s tale pits fifteen year old Betty Kane against socially reticent Marion Sharpe and her forbidding elderly mother.  Kane accuses the two of kidnap and battery, and local lawyer Robert Blair is drawn in by circumstances to investigate.

It’s remarkable how different attitudes to fifteen year olds were in the age before the invention of the teenager.  Although “growing up too quickly” is a common lament these days, there is much more legal protection around our youngsters than there was in the 1940s and there is no way a fifteen year old in a modern novel could be accused of the sort of behaviour that Tey puts the character of Betty under, not without at least some heavy duty psychological explanation.

This lack of characterisation made me think of the contrast with Miles Franklin’s My Brilliant Career, which Rachel put me on to.  Franklin, although much younger than Tey when she wrote her novel (she was sixteen) and writing during a much earlier period, shows much greater understanding of the way environment, social and physical, and experience have a profound effect on the way people turn out.

My Brilliant Career is about a fictional sixteen year old, Sybylla Melvyn.  The novel is set at the end of the nineteenth century in rural Australia.  It’s a tough life, full of struggle, and intensely described.  Just as things are looking the-pits-kind-of-awful, Sybylla gets an opportunity to go and stay with a better off relative, and we follow her adventures as she negotiates adolescence and an up and down relationship with her mother, lurching from poverty to riches to servitude along the way.

Miles Franklin’s own story is also fascinating.  Although she did go on to have a career, which involved writing, the publication of her outspoken first novel was to be the most brilliant part of it. The public assumption that Franklin had written a purely autobiographical work caused her much distress, and she subsequently withdrew it from publication, which is a shame, because as well as her remarkable understanding of personality, the character of Sybylla is so passionate and memorable and easy to relate to.

The other thing that The Franchise Affair reminded me of was Jon Ronson’s You’ve Been Publicly Shamed.  I wasn’t going to read this – too scary – but was lulled in by the Kindle sample, which started off much more gently and humorously than I had expected.  Ronson is at his bemused and beguiling best as he describes what happened when some university students tried to impersonate him on the internet, showing how his helpless outrage turned into a mini crusade, and what happened when the internet swung to his rescue.  Yet it was also this experience that caused him to question the moral momentum behind these movements, and why the public mobilises into self-righteous mobs, and what effect it has on the people who are pursued by them.  In The Franchise Affair, this takes the form of angry locals besieging a house and breaking windows.  You’ve Been… shows how the modern virtual incarnation of mob rule is no less damaging to people’s lives.



  1. What an intriguing combination of reading! I do think the Tey is about class warfare – though I’m not sure any side in it comes out better than any other. It felt to me as if the very awareness of difference caused enough friction to create murderous violence – which is pretty much the fuel powering internet hostilities, too. So no, basically, people do not change, which is a troubling prospect. We don’t get any better at understanding where violence comes from, or at persuading people out of their violent reactions. My Brilliant Career is a book I’ve had on my shelves for ages and I really must read. You have certainly encouraged me to pick it up – it sounds wonderful!

    • Even as a child I used to find the idea of murderous mob rule (which let’s face it is usually caused by difference) frightening, even though it was not something I had ever experienced. Jon Ronson states several times that it is just something we all find very scary. I think it must stem (for both persecutor and imagined persecutee) from some vestigial sense that we all once needed to fit into a group or tribe to ensure our survival.

    • I think it was a case of when you have high expectations, it can alter your reading of a book. I didn’t hate it, and there were some lovely observations of life at the time, but I was so surprised at the way I felt it verged on bad taste.

  2. I loved My Brilliant Career which was why I pinched the title for a few of my posts relating to the odd jobs I’ve done in my life!

    • It’s all coming back to me now! I loved those posts of yours. They were so funny 🙂 I just went back to have a re-read.

      • Well, you didn’t have to do that – but I’m very flattered. It’s a book I’ve remembered so I reckon I must have enjoyed it…I read it back in the days of my actual career😄

  3. Lovely post, I like how one read reminds you of other and you end up discussing three. 🙂 You really make me want to read So You’ve Been Publicly Shamed, scary as it sounds. The blog you have linked to mentions the chapter on Justine Sacco’s “one stupid tweet” and I have read it online too, of course; only I had no idea it was from a book. It was horrible but the kind of horrible you still need to read. He does have a beguiling writing style.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s